Vote for SC2!

[spychi]

"If one person calls you a horse— laugh at him. If a second person calls you a horse— think about it. If a third person calls you a horse— buy a saddle."

or maybe everone else think not rationally but me and DS?
take such POV because I see in my posts valid points put from every perspective I can imagine, I don't side with people I like if they have invalid points, I have my own POV and I usually support them with facts
how people want to write reviews is not my problem, the problem is when people give too much credit because they are fans of the series, just like most people here give too much credit for SC2 which isn't rational thinking
the way I see reviews is to be completly neutral with the series, see all the cons and pros you can see (and even those you don't want to see), give the score for both mp and sp (if available) and pull an average from it
then you have a rate that is objective enough to be belivable
if you want to rate both parts of the game separately, sure go ahead but note this in your review

[DemolitionSquid]

Did Tychus really just call me a horse? Has he been looking though my underwear?

Well, obviously we have a peeping tom on SC:L. He’s climbin’ in your windows, he’s snatchin’ your people up, tryin’ to peep at ‘em. So y’all need to hide your kids, hide your wife, and hide your husband cause they’re peepin at’ everybody out here.

[Gifted]

or maybe everone else think not rationally but me and DS?
take such POV because I see in my posts valid points put from every perspective I can imagine, I don't side with people I like if they have invalid points, I have my own POV and I usually support them with facts
how people want to write reviews is not my problem, the problem is when people give too much credit because they are fans of the series, just like most people here give too much credit for SC2 which isn't rational thinking
the way I see reviews is to be completly neutral with the series, see all the cons and pros you can see (and even those you don't want to see), give the score for both mp and sp (if available) and pull an average from it
then you have a rate that is objective enough to be belivable
if you want to rate both parts of the game separately, sure go ahead but note this in your review

@Spychi:
Since a lot of your comments regard reviews, I suspect you read my wall of text. Let me know if you didn't.

I hope you don't count me as one of the people who basically skewed his opinion due to being a "fanboi". I honestly feel the game, on it's own, stands well. Obviously if I was being more of a fanboi I honestly would have ranked it at minimum a 9... most likely more.

@Tychus
I advise you to take a step back and consider why you're continuing this conversation. I'm not suggesting you should stop it, but I think it will help you explore better discussion in this thread. If your intent is to share your side, consider if you've done that or how to do it better. If your intent is to belittle another's opinion because you believe differently, do you think it will bring progress in this instance? Remember, the definition of insanity is trying to do the same thing repeatedly and expecting a different result.

Did Tychus really just call me a horse? Has he been looking though my underwear?

Well, obviously we have a peeping tom on SC:L. He’s climbin’ in your windows, he’s snatchin’ your people up, tryin’ to peep at ‘em. So y’all need to hide your kids, hide your wife, and hide your husband cause they’re peepin at’ everybody out here.

@Demo:
Man... I really don't want to egg you on. I mean, I truly don't want to....

But this line wins. Great reference.

Hidden Content:

WARNING: This shit will get stuck in your head as much as "Banelings"... DO NOT SAY I DIDN'T WARN YOU!

[Gifted]

Ok, it's official. StarCraft 2 reached the finals. And honestly, I can't agree more that if it's gonna be a popularity contest, it's gonna be as badass as this one...

StarCraft 2 vs Mass Effect 2

[In before Spychi rant]

[Perfecttear]

Hope SC2 takes the final. ME2 was a huge disappointment , and doesn't even deserve to be in the finals at all. Its one of the rare games i played this year and didn't even bother to finish it.

[DemolitionSquid]

Hope SC2 takes the final. ME2 was a huge disappointment , and doesn't even deserve to be in the finals at all. Its one of the rare games i played this year and didn't even bother to finish it.

Everytime you don't kill the human-reaper larva, a puppy dies.

[broodmywarcraft]

Hope SC2 takes the final. ME2 was a huge disappointment , and doesn't even deserve to be in the finals at all. Its one of the rare games i played this year and didn't even bother to finish it.

MASS EFFECT 2 pwns STARCRAFT 2!!

Best game of the year!!

[spychi]

MASS EFFECT 2 pwns STARCRAFT 2!!

Best game of the year!!

QFT, SC 2 should not even be mentioned

[Perfecttear]

Haha , i had a hunch this would hapen

[Louis]

QFT, SC 2 should not even be mentioned

It's funny because ME2 is guilty of a lot of the same flaws as SCII. Except ME2 has no terrific MP to compensate for the very problematic campaign. This 6 part youtube video explains the problems

How you guys can have totally different opinions of games that have so many flaws in common is a mystery.