Amnesia: The dark descent

[TheEconomist]

I haven't read those but, like I said, I don't classify them as "scary" either.

[sandwich_bird]

That was a GREAT game.

Also, it was a game that was almost finished in 1999-2000 but then scrapped. Bethesda picked it up, finished it, and released it. So, basically, it's a 2000 game

Just finished it! Man it was awesome! I so didn't expect the game to turn like this. I mean, in the beginning it's all investigation and stealth and stuff but once you escape the town, the gameplay switch to something similar to half-life.