Results 1 to 2 of 2

Thread: Old but EPIC dream abt D III. sth for an Ex-pacK?

  1. #1

    Default Old but EPIC dream abt D III. sth for an Ex-pacK?

    Here is something i wrote on Blizzforums and battlenet official forums at least a year back. as ive been playing some d2 lately, i got reminded of this, and realzied i wanted to share it; i nver felt it got recognized enough.

    ... If you have any interest in the general direction of Diablo III or non-massive-MP action-RPG's in general, give it a read and tell me what you think. please.

    too lazy to read it all? - its about Competitive questing. how great would it be? combining cooperation, competition PvE and "PvP" in a brand new way of palying Diablo with infrastructure for unique rewards both in form of items / XP , unlocked content(?) and status/reputation/ "ladder position"
    I wouldnt want diablo 3 to be Another standard blizzard titles of late, as in doing everything its expected to in a great way, but not much else, much like WoW combined and perfected elements from other mmorpgs without much TRUE innovation (if you disagree with WoW doing that, this is the wrong place to argue over it anyway - just bare with me!) .. And how SC2 looks to be done by the book, very similar to sc1 considering its over ten years old. (i like this part, but lets not get sidetracked here)

    So im hoping to get something more out of Diablo III than just a major polish of D2 with new environments, monsters, classes, items etc, and fancy stuff like the physics that interact with gameplay.

    What am I looking for then? and why?
    Lets start with the why: Why do people play Diablo past the basic “beat the game” aspect that people do to simply “experience the game” - at the heart of this is issue is really, why do people play action-RPG’s in multiplayer?

    There are two simple answers to this, and I will try to point out how truly designing MP gameplay around BOTH of them at the same time just makes so much sense.

    #1 cooperation this is quite self-explanatory: in MP players can take on challenges that would be too great for them to overcome on their own, and reap the rewards - cooperation has a worth of its own too of course; interaction with others makes the gameplay less predictable etc. However, when the rewards is limited to XP and items that are only used o take on more similar challenges, and when these challenges are completely guided by environment AI, cooperation as incentive WILL get stale and / or predictable sooner or later. - on its OWN that is.

    #2 competition I believe most who play action RPG’s in MP are looking for some sense of completion, even if its sometimes far from as direct as player vs. player combat.. Surely, hunting for treasure, or leveling up really fast, has a competitive aspect for many: to be able to do this faster or more effectively than others - that’s what “being good at the game” means when gathering XP and items by killing monsters are the only rewards the game offers.

    Before I continue the main point;

    What do I mean by Action Rpg’s - why don’t I just talk about Diablo? Put simply: im talking about DotA: I never liked the game, but it brilliantly captures things Diablo is missing: combination & integration of #1 and #2 - a gameplay option to experience more direct action-rpg competition over a more manageable timespan; compared to the indirect & truly endless XP & item hunting of D2 PvE, or the PvP aspect of D2 witch has zero real rewards and is completely cut off from the rest of the game content. (and I think THIS; the combination of cooperation and competition, is what makes DotA popular) .

    .. Obviously, DotA doesnt have lasting characters or other great things connected with these, that make diablo awesome - im just trying to show, combining the goods of these different takes on a-RPG would probably be very fruitfull, if done right.

    getting on with the main point: Diablo II did some great things with cooperative play, but as great ‘a time as we had with that, something was missing (whether you’ve ever realized it or not!) - cooperation sure makes the game last longer, but any fan of any MP game with more direct competitive aspects knows THAT is what truly makes games come alive; even just a sparkle of direct competitive elements integrated into d3 PvE play would do wonders for the overall thrill and motivations to keep improving and diversifying(!) ones character(s).

    so, what do I really mean with “direct competitive elements” ? why don’t I just say PvP?
    Because pvp is only a part of it; PvP makes it sound like killing the other player is the end-all goal of that gameplay situation, as it generally is in RPG pvp, but really, that’s part of what can make it so .. Flat? - to make a DotA anology again: the end all goal ISNT to kill the enemy heroes, but to destroy the enemy main building (tree is it?) … this, along with other nuances like team minions, minion-spawning buildings, towers and creeps makes the whole gameplay experience that much more dynamic - while still remaining directly competitive at heart - because there are two sides with opposite goals!

    So what could be done with Diablo III with regards to this?
    If you understand what im getting at, you’ll know that there are endless ways of doing this, and it can be implemented to a lesser or greater degree: if anyone can get it right, Blizzard can.
    But if you still don’t quite get me, Here is a simple example, ill try to keep it as simple & concrete as possible:
    Two players unknown to each other, pick a game type: “competitive questing 1on1” and are matched against each other anonymously as they enter the game from the lobby. They have two minutes to shop & choose gear before they can start questing

    They then set out on a competitive quest - from two separated locations. The quest objective is a caravan moving from point A to B through a varying landscape stopping sometimes to rest, or to fend off monster ambushes.

    Player X objective is to protect the caravan or failing that, to make sure more than half of its contains gets delivered to point B

    Player Y is to destroy more than half of the contains

    optional more indepth conditions:
    Player X has an NPC caravan-guard to help (friendly, some interaction possible), Player Y is passively aided by Monsters(no direct interaction) that are neutral to Y but aggressive to X and the caravan (the respawn of these monsters can be increased by player Y clearing spawning areas of other mercenary-guards, or decreased by player X(and part of the caravan guard?))

    The player who “wins the quest” claims a reward of items that are not so easy to come by in conventional play, and more importantly the winner “climbs the ladder” in these sense that he will next time be matched against others of similar wealth & Level that have proven equally “skilled” at winning THEIR competitive quests. (think wc3 or sc2 ladder AMM) - the higher up on the ladder, the greater rewards for the winner!

    (lets keep it at that for simplicities’ sake)
    What might happen then? Player X might set out to actively seek out to challenge / cripple player Y or more passively guard the caravan, or seek to take out / soften up monster ambushes.

    Player Y in turn, might seek crippling player X and other obstacles to his mission (AI caravan guards?) or do hit and runs, especially during monster ambushes…

    Both players could also take side quests for “this-quest-only” rewards that help with the main quest, like special potions, items or AI allies.

    The intricate part of this is working out how to deal with direct player v player confrontations; making sure they don’t turn out too fast and simple, and to balance the rewards of killing the other player against the main quest goal.
    Basic XP and items on the characters would remain untouched when killed, but quest items (caravan contains) would be dropped for the other player to interact with. And side quest items / characters should also be affected (like braking, disappearing, becoming available for rehire to anyone…)[INDENT][INDENT][INDENT] So there you have it… one can really think up a lot of theorycraft around this, and I guess it’s as good a pastime as any, I even have more intricate ideas with similar goals: to include some type of “game master/leader” feature, to allow a host of a game to control the creeps & environment against the heroes instead of being one of the heroes… but that stuff is harder to explain and write about in a rational manner, so ill save that for another time.

    Bottom line is, I want to open peoples minds to the idea of a Diablo with more direct competitive elements: it would improve on the game so much, and it needn at all affect those that wouldn’t want to be part of it.
    ... if you read this far, without skipping anything crucial, just level with me, please - is this a direction you would want diablo III to take in an expack? do you think diablo3 players in general could learn to like this direction?

    if not, what is the braking point for you? / what do you think would be the general braking point?

    ... its a big challenge to implement rewarded short-term competition in a way that cannot be abused, but the important part is just the general idea and direction - the realization of how awesome it could be - and the firm belief that blizzard could make it happen at some point. - it would all be worth it.

    do you get me? are you with me?

    finally, whats a good big diablo community-forum to post this in?

    thx for reading... or trying to read. :P

    I am an enthusiast of good strategy games, sc2Esports and rollplay, although i dont really play anything atm.
    I work an internship at a government agency this fall, and have a good time at it.
    I'm being more social, active and honest lately. in all forums.


  2. #2

    Default Re: Old but EPIC dream abt D III. sth for an Ex-pacK?

    Sounds great. I don't really have much do add, besides saying that I read it :P It would be pretty awesome if it would add more of a player vs player or team vs team. But in a non-player vs player focused event. (I got no idea how to do that, so if they find out it would probably be awesome)

Similar Threads

  1. Epic PvZ Build
    By Andromines in forum StarCraft Discussion
    Replies: 25
    Last Post: 09-15-2010, 03:40 AM
  2. [Replays] Siraz's Replay Pack
    By Siraz in forum StarCraft Discussion
    Replies: 0
    Last Post: 09-01-2010, 06:53 PM
  3. Dream come true or worst nightmare?
    By n00bonicPlague in forum Off-Topic Lounge
    Replies: 3
    Last Post: 08-31-2010, 11:37 PM
  4. Dream Diary
    By Visions of Khas in forum Off-Topic Lounge
    Replies: 6
    Last Post: 07-13-2010, 09:55 AM
  5. We got our first SC:L Dream Team!
    By LXM in forum StarCraft Discussion
    Replies: 5
    Last Post: 02-23-2010, 11:48 AM

Tags for this Thread

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts