
Originally Posted by
Peanutbutter
In PvZ 2 gate pressure might be useful again, especially since many zerg go hatch first these days.
In PvT, it's useless since marines and marauders kite zealots.
Let's talk PvP. First of all, you didn't include cannons or a forge in the BO. Without them, you'll die 100% to any kind of one base pressure ( 3 gate robo, 4 gate, 3 gate blink stalkers ) and especially DT's. At least one cannon is required.
If i see you put down 2 gates, and chronoboosting them, I'll immediately do this same. I might even come out a bit ahead, since i'll probably have more probes by then.
You'll only have zealots, which means that i should theoretically be able to keep my scout alive forever. As soon as i see an expansion, i'll just out-zealot you : )
Let's talk 4 gate.
In the new patch, assuming constant chronoboost, a 4 WG rush will arrive 20 seconds later that it does before ( It arrives at around 5:30 now, will arrive at around 6 after patch ). At this point, I'll have 6 stalkers and one zealot, and you'll have 6 zealots. Unless you put a cannon at the bottom of your ramp, i'll contain you, thus preventing any kind of expansion until you get enough stalkers. I'll continually get stalkers, meaning that you're going to need more cannons.
After I've pressured you enough, and force 2-3 extra cannons, i'll safely transition into blink with an observer, and kill you right there and then.
A 3 gate robo might be a bit more weak, considering you're going mass zealot in the beginning, but i think that it will be manageable w some forcefields.
So, the FE build basically loses to every common protoss build out there. You can transition well into any aggressive build from a 2 gate, so i don't see this working. Hiding the expo is out of the question, since any decent protoss will notice that somethings wrong.
Also, in PvT and PvZ there are much safer FE builds.
A simple forge FE in PvZ is better for establishing an early game economy, aimed for the mid game. 3 gate sentry FE is the safest FE build in PvZ atm.
In PvT 1 gate FE, 3 gate FE, and 2gate robo are the only viable FE builds.