Search:

Type: Posts; User: MattII

Page 1 of 20 1 2 3 4

Search: Search took 0.22 seconds.

  1. Replies
    40
    Views
    7,078

    Re: Why there was no fourth race

    Nah, they should put them in as either 'heroes' or 'critters'.
  2. Replies
    37
    Views
    5,394

    Re: Let's discuss the mothership

    I can go for this, and in fact I personally think both the MShip and Carrier should be consigned to campaigns/scenarios and replaced with a DT themed attacker-spellcaster. to fill the 'command-ship'...
  3. Replies
    47
    Views
    11,569

    Re: Firefly similarities

    Kinda how the whole thing was taken from the 'Starship Troopers' novel by Robert Heinlein.
  4. Replies
    37
    Views
    5,394

    Re: Let's discuss the mothership

    Well as it stands, Zerg have 13 units (not including spawns), Terran have 14, and Protoss have 15, so I'd be quite happy to just drop the MShip.
  5. Replies
    47
    Views
    11,569

    Re: Firefly similarities

    A bit OT, but while Knights Of The Realm in space makes no real sense, space westerns in general are actually a fairly workable genre, if used carefully.
  6. Re: People who think SC2 is getting worse after every update are hypocrits

    Philippines, UK, Canada, US, Austria, this is supposed to be an 'isolated' incident?
  7. Poll: Re: Does the protoss need a cheep air unit that can attack ground?

    Except that it doesn't work like that, you have to outlay 350/250 right at the start and wait 120 seconds before you can even move them.
  8. Poll: Re: Does the protoss need a cheep air unit that can attack ground?

    Except that it goes from AtA to GtG, not AtG (the difference is what can hit it, which for the Viking-ground is just about everything except those that are dedicated AtA and GtA). The Banshee is the...
  9. Poll: Re: Does the protoss need a cheep air unit that can attack ground?

    Well that's a non-sequitur.
  10. Replies
    34
    Views
    4,131

    Re: Ghost - caster to a viable combat unit

    What about replacing Snipe with an ability similar to the old Nomad 'Targetting Drone' ability (so that the Ghost can't do anything else while he's targetting an enemy unit).
  11. Poll: Re: Does the protoss need a cheep air unit that can attack ground?

    If VR is the answer to pretty much anything then it's too good and needs to be brought down a bit, ie, by re-instituting the power drop after each kill.
  12. Poll: Re: Does the protoss need a cheep air unit that can attack ground?

    IMO the Carrier is too expensive to cover the anti-light AtG role so they need to replace it with a weaker (250/200 hp/shields) unit with no/weak AtA.
  13. Replies
    90
    Views
    12,094

    Poll: Re: [Idea] Poll: Void Ray Replaces Carrier

    Or missiles (I've long held the opinion that they should have replaced the Carrier with a unit that employs the MShip's AtG missiles).
  14. Poll: Re: Does the protoss need a cheep air unit that can attack ground?

    Actually, 'no' is implied by options 3 and 4, take your pick.
  15. Replies
    28
    Views
    5,336

    Poll: Re: Do you like the Thor?

    Hey, maybe Heart of the Swarm will replace rather than add units.
  16. Thread: Thor too small?

    by MattII
    Replies
    84
    Views
    9,366

    Re: Thor too small?

    Actually, the Thor isn't the Goliath for two very obvious reasons anti-light GtA and high damage GtG, in fact it is pretty much the Goliath reversed.
  17. Replies
    90
    Views
    12,094

    Poll: Re: [Idea] Poll: Void Ray Replaces Carrier

    Because it had exactly 0 shields against AtA attacks, and Protoss units always have shields (reduced to 0 points maybe, but never not there).
  18. Replies
    90
    Views
    12,094

    Poll: Re: [Idea] Poll: Void Ray Replaces Carrier

    Maybe, but the shield mechanic was thoroughly un-Protossy, and apart from the mechanic it was basically a facelifted Carrier.



    Yep it did, but it was as much Blizzard's refusal to really try...
  19. Replies
    90
    Views
    12,094

    Poll: Re: [Idea] Poll: Void Ray Replaces Carrier

    Sorry, you want to replace an existing unit with the very unit it replaced (which is, let's face it, basically the existing unit with a new mechanic, and thus, doesn't really warrant a name change...
  20. Replies
    90
    Views
    12,094

    Poll: Re: [Idea] Poll: Void Ray Replaces Carrier

    Well if we had one for the Phoenix and another one for the VR it'd make the Fleet Beacon a bit more enticing, and thus the Carrier might see a bit more use, if only because people would be more...
  21. Replies
    90
    Views
    12,094

    Poll: Re: [Idea] Poll: Void Ray Replaces Carrier

    No thanks, they just need to give the Fleet beacon a few more techs (the old one had like 4, 2 of which were for the Scout).
  22. Thread: Thor Re-Model

    by MattII
    Replies
    62
    Views
    8,644

    Re: Thor Re-Model

    The problem here was Blizzard's absolute refusal to touch the ST beyond stats changes, that basically forced them to either repeat the SC mech lineup (though they at least 'tried' to refresh it, but...
  23. Re: Brainlings (Fixing Zerg so Lurkers can come back)

    This is the blasted problem, no-one knew what to expect from SC, but now they've been playing SC for years they want SC2 to be pretty similar, except that it's a new game, not an expansion, so there...
  24. Replies
    17
    Views
    3,056

    Re: Additional Models for Minerals and X'N Towers

    How about few more X'N gadgets, ie, a tower that gives the owner Detection over a good radius, or blocks enemy Detection in certain radius, or hels allied units in a certain radius, or shields units...
  25. Thread: Thor Re-Model

    by MattII
    Replies
    62
    Views
    8,644

    Re: Thor Re-Model

    Thanks Crazy.
Results 1 to 25 of 500
Page 1 of 20 1 2 3 4