Search:

Type: Posts; User: DarthYam

Page 1 of 10 1 2 3 4

Search: Search took 0.01 seconds.

  1. Replies
    251
    Views
    30,496

    Re: How to Rework Starcraft II

    The idea was that learning the full depth's of Amon's plans, loosing everything (at this point he's even more powerless than in BW, since the Tal'darim are the ones in control, knowing Kerrigan's out...
  2. Replies
    251
    Views
    30,496

    Re: How to Rework Starcraft II

    That's not quite what I was doing; Kerrigan would have spared the Protoss on Kaldir in part because one of the captives would have been a small child; seeing the child scared strikes a chord in...
  3. Replies
    251
    Views
    30,496

    Re: How to Rework Starcraft II

    Here's a sort of outline for HOTS that I think tries to address the problems (Amon and his forces not being relevant except for Skygierr; Kerrigan being nastier than she should)

    Intro: The Moebius...
  4. Replies
    251
    Views
    30,496

    Re: How to Rework Starcraft II

    I said before how when Heart of the Swarm first had details released Lassara would be spared. Kerrigan would strike up a rapport with her and earn her respect and even friendship.

    I'd also have...
  5. Replies
    251
    Views
    30,496

    Re: How to Rework Starcraft II

    I've referred to the Moros as Kerrigan's Heel Realization. The way she's been justifying what she's been doing is to "avenge" Raynor. When the man she's using to justify her actions directly calls...
  6. Replies
    251
    Views
    30,496

    Re: How to Rework Starcraft II

    1.) Telematros
    2.) The Miners of the Kel Morian Combine

    Kerrigan had a reason to go on the warpath, and the reason she did spare the people on Korhal wasn't "She'd have had to morph a couple more...
  7. Replies
    251
    Views
    30,496

    Re: How to Rework Starcraft II

    There's a difference between attacking a military base and attacking civilians. Kerrigan also had a reason; the most important thing is that she does genuinely change for the better. That's why her...
  8. Replies
    251
    Views
    30,496

    Re: How to Rework Starcraft II

    I have. It was short sighted. Kerrigan could have been somewhat nicer and I agree Kaldir was unnecessary (again the original version at blizzcon had her be nicer to the colonists) but I think that in...
  9. Replies
    251
    Views
    30,496

    Re: How to Rework Starcraft II

    WOL had problems; they should have had a linear storyline, Raynor should have made more mistakes.
    HOTS had problems: Kerrigan should have been more conflicted, more time should have spent with...
  10. Replies
    251
    Views
    30,496

    Re: How to Rework Starcraft II

    With Lassara KERRIGAN HERSELF feels guilt for what happens and acknowledges what she did was wrong. An important thing is that SHE DID CHANGE. During Korhal she had no reason to believe Jim would...
  11. Replies
    251
    Views
    30,496

    Re: How to Rework Starcraft II

    Not even remotely comparable. Kerrigan actually feels remorse in heart of the swarm, has a more believable motivation for going on the war path (she's lost any chance at normalcy to the same asshole...
  12. Replies
    251
    Views
    30,496

    Re: How to Rework Starcraft II

    I sort of see where you're coming from. She's so filled with anger and sorrow from her loss that she sees anyone in the way of her vengeance as an obstacle. Even then she felt somewhat bad about...
  13. Replies
    251
    Views
    30,496

    Re: How to Rework Starcraft II

    I think it's a pretty interesting idea; technically it WAS xel'naga who uplifted the protoss and it gives a reason for Amon. I think that the idea of the Good Xel'naga discovering what Amon was up...
  14. Replies
    251
    Views
    30,496

    Re: How to Rework Starcraft II

    I liked the version of the final battle of the el naga we got in Legacy. That Amon was interrupted

    it adds meaning to his "as i was your beginning so shall I be your end." Line. He made them. It...
  15. Replies
    251
    Views
    30,496

    Re: How to Rework Starcraft II

    the manual said the xel'naga uplifted the protoss. Amon and his crew were Xel'naga. Technically it's not a retcon; it's just that another FACTION did the uplifting.

    Kerrigan's redemption could...
  16. Replies
    251
    Views
    30,496

    Re: How to Rework Starcraft II

    the manual said the xel'naga uplifted the protoss. Amon and his crew were Xel'naga. Technically it's not a retcon; it's just that another FACTION did the uplifting.

    Kerrigan's redemption could...
  17. Replies
    251
    Views
    30,496

    Re: How to Rework Starcraft II

    Maybe so. I think that Kerrigan's redemption could have worked. The idea of a mortal becoming a villain, loosing their power and going on a journey of self discovery is interesting. You could get...
  18. Replies
    251
    Views
    30,496

    Re: How to Rework Starcraft II

    Lots of great ideas there but I think that a compromise with Kerrigan is better. I suggested that things like the zerg mutagen and Amon's taint simply amplified a darkness that was already there and...
  19. Replies
    251
    Views
    30,496

    Re: How to Rework Starcraft II

    Fanatic Templar went into detail about how Kerrigan was actually a.) incompetent and b.) inconsistent. Aldrius basically put his hands in his ears and said LALALALALALALALALA I'm not listening...
  20. Replies
    251
    Views
    30,496

    Re: How to Rework Starcraft II

    1.) We seem to have differing views. I liked HOTS kerrigan because she actually evolves over the course of the story.

    To quote Hawki "So, on one hand, we have BW Kerrigan who sings the same tune...
  21. Replies
    251
    Views
    30,496

    Re: How to Rework Starcraft II

    Maybe I was uncharitable. I felt that the idea of a Kerrigan who'se introspective is a fine idea rather than a bad one. I'm also annoyed at how people are always going on about how SO MUCH BETTER...
  22. Replies
    251
    Views
    30,496

    Re: How to Rework Starcraft II

    I'll be honest. Aldrius is looking through rose colored glasses. I watched the cinematic of brood war and youtube and all I thought was that Kerrigan was bland and one note evil. She was one...
  23. Replies
    251
    Views
    30,496

    Re: How to Rework Starcraft II

    I agree in as much as Heart of the Swarm. In the original outline, Kerrigan was going to be a lot nicer. She would have spared Lassara and the other protoss, and she would have ultimately found...
  24. Replies
    251
    Views
    30,496

    Re: How to Rework Starcraft II

    Part of the reason I mentioned Charles Whitman is that it could have had Kerrigan being in control and still having outside factors influence her. Whitman ultimately made the choices he did but the...
  25. Replies
    251
    Views
    30,496

    Re: How to Rework Starcraft II

    I was expecting Kerrigan to be more....hot blooded. She's cold in brood war. I expected her to be more vengeful, more obsessed with making Mengsk suffer. Fanatic said that if they did what they did...
Results 1 to 25 of 246
Page 1 of 10 1 2 3 4